Indianapolis carries more than a century of history in its brick buildings and quiet basements. Beneath its modern skyline sits a city with a layered, sometimes dark, past—one that includes Prohibition-era bootlegging, notorious outlaws, and even the Underground Railroad. That history has left behind a trail of ghost stories that locals still swap over drinks today.
Few buildings embody this better than the structure at 372 S. Meridian Street, downtown. Known today as the Slippery Noodle Inn, it began its life in 1850 as the Tremont House. Across its 170-plus years, the building has worn many names and served many purposes, and each chapter of its story has added a new layer of legend.
In this guide, you’ll learn the real history behind Indianapolis’s most talked-about haunted location, the ghost stories associated with it, and a few other sites worth exploring if you’re drawn to the paranormal. We’ll also point you toward a great spot to grab a bite once you’re done exploring.

The Tremont House: Where Indianapolis’s Most Haunted Story Begins
Before it became known for blues music and ghost stories, the building at 372 S. Meridian Street opened in 1850 as a roadhouse and bar called the Tremont House. It’s one of the oldest commercial buildings in Indianapolis, and according to the Slippery Noodle’s own history, it’s the longest continually operated bar still standing in its original building.
A Possible Underground Railroad Stop
Local lore holds that the Tremont House may have played a role in the Underground Railroad. In a 2018 interview with CBS4, event coordinator Sara Etherington said formerly enslaved people may have hidden in the building’s basement before continuing north. She described an unsettling feeling in parts of that basement, saying “something just doesn’t feel right.” This connection is part of the building’s oral history rather than a documented fact, but it’s one of the most frequently repeated stories tied to the site.
A Brothel With a Violent Past
According to a now-removed page from the bar’s own website, the building operated as a brothel until 1853. The story goes that two customers got into an argument over a woman, and the fight ended in a killing, with the bloody knife left behind on the bar. Like much of the building’s folklore, this claim comes from the business itself and hasn’t been independently verified, but it’s become a core part of the haunted history passed down through the years.
The Slippery Noodle’s Haunted History
After its early years as the Tremont House, the building passed through several identities. It became the Concordia House in the 1860s, one of Indianapolis’s early German social clubs, then Germania House, and later Beck’s Saloon around World War I. During Prohibition, owner Walter Moore renamed it Moore’s Restaurant, all while beer and whiskey were reportedly still being produced in the basement.
Dillinger’s Gang and Bullet-Scarred Walls
Once Prohibition ended, the bar attracted a different kind of clientele. John Dillinger’s gang, active across Indiana and Ohio in the early 1930s, is said to have frequented the building. Bullet slugs are still reportedly lodged in the basement walls today, believed to be remnants of target practice from that era.
How the Slippery Noodle Got Its Name
Harold and Lorean Yeagy took over the business on Friday, December 13, 1963, and gave it the name it carries today: The Slippery Noodle. Their son Hal took the reins in 1985 and transformed it from a lunch counter into the blues club Indianapolis knows now. Hal Yeagy passed away in 2020, and the business changed hands for the first time in 60 years when Jason Amonett and Sean Lothridge purchased it in 2023.
The Ghosts Said to Haunt the Slippery Noodle
Over the decades, patrons and staff have reported a handful of recurring apparitions:
- George – A former caretaker, nicknamed by regulars, said to appear in the basement wearing overalls and occasionally startling workers delivering kegs.
- The cowboy – Believed by some to be the victim of the brothel-era knife fight, this apparition is said to linger near where the altercation allegedly occurred.
- Phantom women – Visitors have reported seeing female figures on the second floor, tied to the building’s brothel-era past.
- Formerly enslaved people – Some say figures connected to the building’s Underground Railroad history have been spotted in the basement.
Psychic Gary Spivey visited the building and reported seeing a “spiritual hand” reaching up from the basement floor, along with George and a female entity on the second floor he described as “the madam of the brothel.” Hal Yeagy once hosted haunted tours of the building, compiling many of these stories into the lore that circulates today.
It’s worth noting that these accounts are folklore, not verified paranormal evidence. The Slippery Noodle itself no longer promotes its haunted reputation the way it once did. As Etherington put it, “There are some people who come here specifically because they want to see if they can feel a presence or see something with their own eyes.”
Today, the Slippery Noodle operates seven days a week into the early morning hours, with live blues on two stages most nights.
Other Haunted Sites Worth Exploring in Indianapolis
If the Slippery Noodle has you curious about more of the city’s paranormal lore, a few other locations are worth a visit.
Hannah House
Built in 1858 by Alexander Moore Hannah, this 24-room Italianate mansion at 3801 Madison Avenue is said to have served as an Underground Railroad station. Legend tells of a basement fire and a lingering odor that visitors still report today, along with sightings of Hannah’s own ghost. The home is listed on the National Register of Historic Places and hosts tours and events periodically—check current schedules before visiting.
Central State Hospital
Operating as a psychiatric institution from 1848 to 1994, the former Central State Hospital grounds carry their own share of reported hauntings tied to the site’s long and difficult history.
Allison Mansion, Indiana Repertory Theatre, and Rivoli Theatre
Built in 1911, the Allison Mansion has its own collection of ghost stories, as does the Indiana Repertory Theatre, constructed in 1927. The Rivoli Theatre, which opened the same year, is home to local legends of a “phantom projectionist” said to appear in the building.
Tips for Exploring Indianapolis’s Haunted Locations
A few common threads run through Indianapolis’s ghost stories: basements tied to difficult histories, buildings with Underground Railroad connections, and apparitions linked to violent or sudden deaths. If you want to explore these sites yourself, keep a few things in mind.
- Visit during open hours. Stick to regular business hours or scheduled tours, and never trespass at closed or private sites.
- Go with a group. It’s safer, and honestly more fun, to explore these stories with friends.
- Plan ahead in October. Haunted tour season peaks in the fall, so book any ghost walks or guided tours in advance.
- Respect the history. Many of these buildings are tied to real, sometimes painful, chapters of Indianapolis’s past. Treat the stories, and the spaces, with respect.
Several tour operators, including Ghost City Tours and Unseenpress, run regular ghost walks through downtown Indianapolis that include stops at the Slippery Noodle and other haunted sites. Schedules and offerings change, so check current listings before you go.
Refuel After Your Ghost Hunt at English Ivy’s Eatery & Pub
After a night of tracking down Indianapolis’s ghost stories, you’ll want somewhere to unwind. English Ivy’s Eatery & Pub, located at 944 N. Alabama Street in the Historic Saint Joseph Neighborhood, offers exactly that. This LGBTQ-friendly neighborhood pub sits in a building with its own historic roots, fitting right into Downtown Indianapolis’s mix of old charm and local character.
English Ivy’s is open Monday through Saturday from 11:00 AM to 2:00 AM and Sunday from 10:00 AM to 2:00 AM, making it an easy stop whether your haunted tour wraps up early or runs late into the night.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are the Indianapolis ghost stories real or just folklore?
Most of these stories are passed-down local legends rather than documented fact. Some details, like the Dillinger gang’s visits or the building’s many name changes, are historically recorded. Others, like specific ghost sightings, come from personal accounts and business lore that haven’t been independently verified.
Can you actually visit these haunted locations?
Yes. The Slippery Noodle operates as a working bar seven days a week, and sites like Hannah House offer periodic public tours. Always check current hours and schedules before visiting, especially around October when demand increases.
What’s the most famous ghost story in Indianapolis?
The ghosts tied to the Slippery Noodle, including “George” the caretaker and the brothel-era apparitions, are among the most widely told ghost stories in the city, partly due to the building’s long and layered history.
Are there guided ghost tours available in Indianapolis?
Yes. Companies like Ghost City Tours and Unseenpress run regular ghost walks through downtown Indianapolis, often including stops at the Slippery Noodle and other historic sites. Check their current schedules for availability.
Explore Indianapolis’s Past, One Haunted Building at a Time
From the Tremont House’s murky 1850s origins to the Slippery Noodle’s blues-filled present, Indianapolis holds onto its history in ways you can see, hear, and maybe even feel. Hannah House, Central State Hospital, and the Rivoli Theatre round out a city with no shortage of ghost stories to explore.
Whether you’re drawn in by the history or the mystery, take some time to walk through these storied buildings yourself. And when you’re ready to warm up and swap stories from the night, stop by English Ivy’s Eatery & Pub in Downtown Indianapolis for a drink and a bite in a space that holds a little bit of local history itself.
Related Posts:
Spooky Sips: Top Halloween Cocktails to Try This Year
How to Cure a Halloween Hangover
What to Do Near Lucas Oil Stadium Before or After a Colts Game









