Downtown Indianapolis is home to a vibrant and diverse nightlife scene. From cozy pubs to high-energy spots with live music, there’s something for everyone in Indy’s bar scene. Whether you’re a local, a tourist, or a young professional looking for a fun night out, planning your own bar crawl is the perfect way to explore the city and enjoy its variety of bars.
But where do you start? Don’t worry—we’ve got you covered. This guide will walk you through all the steps for planning the ultimate Indianapolis bar crawl, from choosing the bars to ensuring everyone has a safe and unforgettable experience.

Step 1: Plan Your Bar Crawl Like a Pro
A successful bar crawl begins with careful planning. Here are a few key elements to define before heading out:
Choose a Theme
While optional, having a theme can add a fun twist to your evening. Whether it’s a throwback “80s Night”, a sports fan crawl during game season, or national holiday (e.g. St. Patrick’s Day or Memorial Day), a theme makes your crawl feel more organized and memorable.
Set a Budget
Be mindful of how much you want to spend. Consider covering the costs of drinks, snacks, transport, and tips. Some bars in Indy offer specials or happy hour deals, so researching these ahead of time can make a big difference. Typically, $40-$60 per person is a reasonable budget for a casual crawl.
Decide on Group Size
Smaller groups—think 4 to 10 people—are more manageable and make it easier to stick together. Larger groups can still work, but it may require more coordination and reservations, depending on the bars you visit.
Step 2: Choosing the Right Bars
The Downtown Indianapolis bar scene offers a variety of options, so mix things up to create an exciting route that keeps everyone entertained.
Include a Mix of Venues
Create diversity in your lineup. For example:
- Start your night with casual drinks and bites at Kilroy’s, famous for their stuffed breadsticks and casual vibe.
- Swing by Howl at the Moon, a lively dueling piano bar where you can belt out your favorite tunes.
- Add some charm with a stop at English Ivy’s Eatery & Pub, a comfortable LGBTQ-friendly spot with welcoming vibes.
- Cap off your crawl with a German twist by visiting Rathskeller, where the beer garden offers authentic brews and a great atmosphere.
Prioritize Convenience
Choose bars that are close to one another to minimize travel time. Many Downtown Indy bars are just a short walk apart, making bar crawls a breeze. Use the Indianapolis Cultural Trail as a guide for nearby venues.
Highlight Inclusivity
Include LGBTQ-friendly venues or specialty bars to ensure everyone in your group feels welcome. English Ivy’s, for instance, is a must-visit for its friendly atmosphere and standout cocktails.
Watch for Deals
Check out happy hours or daily specials when planning your route. Many Indianapolis bars offer drink discounts during select hours—perfect for saving money while enjoying great drinks.
Step 3: Get Around the Right Way
Navigating Downtown Indy is easy with plenty of transportation options. Here are some ways to get around safely while keeping the fun going:
- Walking: Downtown Indy is pedestrian-friendly, and many great bars are within walking distance of each other.
- Ride-Sharing: Services like Uber and Lyft make it easy to travel between farther locations or get back home safely at the end of the night.
- Scooter Rentals: Rentable scooters are a fun, quick way to zip between venues while enjoying the fresh air.
- Public Transportation: The IndyGo Red Line can help you reach bars outside the main downtown area.
- Designated Driver: If someone in your group is staying sober, that’s always a reliable (and appreciated) option.
Step 4: Stay Safe While Having Fun
The primary goal of any bar crawl is to have fun—but safety should always be a priority. Here are some tips to ensure a worry-free experience:
- Hydrate: Drink water between alcoholic beverages to stay hydrated throughout the night.
- Pace Yourself: Know your limits and avoid overindulging. The crawl is about enjoying the evening, not ending it early!
- Stick with Your Group: Use the buddy system and keep an eye on each other to avoid getting separated.
- Eat First: Start the night with a filling meal to slow alcohol absorption. Many bars, like English Ivy’s and Kilroy’s, also serve great snacks and meals if you need to refuel mid-crawl.
- Plan Transportation: Ensure you have a safe and reliable way to return home, such as a ride-share or designated driver.
- Save Emergency Contacts: Have someone from outside the crawl aware of your plans and your location, just in case.
Key Takeaways
Planning your own bar crawl in Downtown Indianapolis is more than just visiting one bar after another—it’s about curating an experience. By choosing a mix of venues, planning your route responsibly, and taking steps to ensure safety, your bar crawl can be an exciting night out that everyone will talk about for weeks.
Looking for more inspiration? Share your experiences with friends, or better yet, invite them along for a round two! Start planning your ultimate Indianapolis bar crawl today and explore the best that Downtown Indy has to offer.
Happy crawling! 🍻
We hope this guide has given you an idea of what a Downtown Indy bar crawl can look like. Start your exploration at English Ivy’s Eatery & Pub! No reservations required. Enjoy a wide menu selection of lunch and dinner options, plus drink specials, all at neighborhood prices!
Related Posts:
Discover the Thrills of Downtown Indianapolis: Your Ultimate Guide
Free Things to Do in Downtown Indianapolis: A Budget-Friendly Adventure
The Best Places to Watch the Game in Downtown Indianapolis