3 Espresso Martini Variations Every Coffee Lover Should Try

The espresso martini has earned its place as a timeless cocktail, and for good reason. It delivers the rich, roasted depth of coffee alongside the warmth of good spirits, creating a drink that feels indulgent and energizing in equal measure. British bartender Dick Bradsell first crafted this drink in 1980s London, reportedly after a customer asked for something to wake her up. Decades later, it remains a fixture on cocktail menus worldwide.

What many drinkers don’t realize is that the espresso martini isn’t a one-note order. Small changes to the base recipe can shift the entire character of the drink, from silky and mellow to bold and citrus-forward. Whether you’re a longtime fan or ordering one for the first time, knowing your options helps you find the pour that suits your palate.

This guide walks through three popular espresso martini variations—Traditional, Creamy, and Tequila—so you can order with confidence next time you’re at the bar.

The Traditional Espresso Martini

The traditional espresso martini is the version that started it all. It relies on a simple, well-balanced combination: vodka, coffee liqueur, and freshly pulled espresso, shaken hard with ice and strained into a chilled glass.

What Goes Into a Classic Espresso Martini?

A standard pour typically includes:

Vodka: A smooth, neutral spirit that lets the coffee take center stage
Coffee liqueur: Usually Kahlúa, adding sweetness and depth
Fresh espresso: The heart of the drink, providing bold, roasted flavor
Simple syrup: A touch of sweetness to round out the bitterness of the coffee

The mixture is shaken vigorously, which is what creates that signature frothy, latte-colored crema on top. Most bartenders finish the drink with three coffee beans as a garnish—a nod to the traditional Italian Sambuca custom, where the beans are said to represent health, wealth, and happiness.

Why This Version Remains a Bar Staple

The traditional recipe works because it strikes a careful balance. The vodka keeps things crisp rather than syrupy, while the espresso ensures the drink tastes like a proper cocktail instead of a dessert in a glass. It’s the version most bartenders know how to make well, and it’s a reliable order no matter where you are.

The Creamy Espresso Martini

For drinkers who want a softer, more dessert-like experience, the creamy espresso martini swaps out some of the sharpness of the original for richness. This variation typically incorporates Irish cream liqueur, like Baileys, either alongside or in place of a portion of the coffee liqueur.

How Cream Changes the Drink

Adding Irish cream transforms the mouthfeel of the cocktail. Instead of the clean, slightly bitter finish of the traditional version, the creamy espresso martini delivers a smoother, silkier texture with notes of vanilla and caramel. The espresso still provides plenty of coffee flavor, but the overall effect is rounder and more forgiving for those who find the classic recipe a bit too strong or bitter.

Best Occasions to Order the Creamy Version

This variation shines as an after-dinner drink or dessert substitute. If you’re winding down a meal and want something that feels indulgent without ordering a slice of cake, the creamy espresso martini fits the bill. It’s also a great entry point for anyone new to espresso martinis who wants a gentler introduction before trying the more spirit-forward original.

The Tequila Espresso Martini

The tequila espresso martini takes the boldest departure from tradition, swapping vodka for tequila. It’s a modern spin that’s gained traction for good reason: tequila’s citrus and pepper notes complement coffee’s bitterness in a way that feels unexpected but works remarkably well.

Why Tequila Works With Coffee

Silver (blanco) tequila tends to bring grassy, citrus, and peppery notes to the glass, while aged varieties like reposado or añejo introduce warmer flavors like vanilla, caramel, and baking spice. Many versions of this cocktail also include a splash of orange liqueur, such as Cointreau, along with a touch of vanilla syrup to tie the citrus and coffee flavors together. The result is a drink that’s bold, slightly spiced, and more complex than the traditional pour.

When to Choose Tequila Over Vodka

If you’re a fan of margaritas or tequila-based cocktails and want to try something with more depth, this variation is worth ordering. It’s also a great choice if you find vodka-based cocktails a little flat—the tequila adds a layer of warmth and character that makes each sip more interesting.

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s the best time to order an espresso martini?

Espresso martinis work well after dinner thanks to their caffeine kick, but they’re equally popular as a pre-dinner drink or a late-night order when you want something with a bit of energy behind it.

Can I make any of these at home?

Yes. All three variations can be made with a cocktail shaker, fresh espresso, and the appropriate spirits. The key is using freshly pulled, slightly cooled espresso and shaking hard enough to build that signature frothy top.

Which variation is strongest?

The traditional and tequila versions tend to feel more spirit-forward, since neither includes cream to soften the pour. The creamy version often feels lighter on the palate, even though the alcohol content is comparable across all three.

Find Your Favorite Pour

Each of these espresso martini variations offers something different, whether you’re after the balanced classic, the smooth and creamy dessert-like pour, or the bold citrus kick of tequila. The best way to find your favorite is simple: try all three.

Ready to taste them for yourself? Head to English Ivy’s Eatery & Pub in Indianapolis, Indiana, where our bartenders craft each variation with care. Stop by on a Monday and enjoy our weekly special—$4 Effen vodka—while you sip your way through the menu.

Visit English Ivy’s Menus